FILM REVIEW: Ridley Scott’s ‘American Gangster’

american-gangster x650

By Ray Bennett

Ridley Scott has been saying in interviews lately that he likes to make his movies quickly. Maybe that’s why “American Gangster,” which opens in the U.K. Friday, lacks his customary visual flair.

It’s a workmanlike crime picture but there’s little of the Scott style that made everything from “The Duelists” to “Blade Runner” to “Black Hawk Down” so arresting.

Steven Zaillian’s script lacks memorable dialogue and the performances by Denzel Washington and especially Russell Crowe are merely professional. Marc Streitenfeld’s music is nothing to write home about either.

It’s long and disappointing so it’s a puzzle that the film is on so many tipsters’ lists for awards contention. But then, Martin Scorsese’s wretched “The Departed” won the Oscar last year. Lots of critics like “American Gangster,” but I think Stephanie Zacharek gets it right in her review on Salon:

“American Gangster” offers only the stingiest platform for its actors, and as a piece of storytelling — built on the foundation of a great story — it’s an epic that’s been sliced and diced into so many little morsels that almost nothing in it has any weight.”

Posted in Film, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on FILM REVIEW: Ridley Scott’s ‘American Gangster’

FILM REVIEW: Werner Herzog’s ‘Rescue Dawn’

Jeremy Davies aand Christian Bale Rescue Dawn Movie Image

By Ray Bennett

Filmmaker Werner Herzog was in a playful mood Monday evening in a Q&A following a BAFTA screening of his new movie “Rescue Dawn” at the Curzon Soho in London.

An often harrowing but ultimately uplifting real life tale starring Christian Bale as an American POW in Laos in the mid-1960s, the film has a surprising number of comic moments.

Arriving after the film had ended, Herzog asked if the audience had laughed. Interviewer Mark Kermode said yes and he added, “And in all the right places.”

The director promptly corrected him: “The audience never laughs in the wrong place. Audiences have an instinctive intelligence about that. If they do laugh unexpectedly it’s because there is something wrong with the film.”

One of the funniest lines in the picture comes when Bale’s character, Dieter Dengler, who was born in Germany during World War II, describes how he fell in love with the idea of flying after he was shot at by an Allied fighter pilot. Steve Zahn, as a fellow prisoner, says, “Funny, some guy tries to kill you and you want his job.”

Bale’s vivid description echoes the scene in Steven Spielberg’s “Empire of the Sun” when the kid he plays watches planes from the roof of a bombed building. When asked about it, Herzog said that had nothing to with it, the scene derived only from Dengler’s memoirs, which were seen in Herzog’s documentary 1997 documentary “Little Dieter Needs to Fly.” Still, fans of what remains Spielberg’s finest picture will make the connection.

Bale and Zahn, and a frighteningly skinny Jeremy Davies (pictured with Bale), are terrific in a film that did not really get a shot at the U.S. box office in the summer.

It opens in the U.K. on Nov. 23. Peter Zeitlinger’s cinematography in the jungle is outstanding as is Klaus Badelt’s sturdy and spiritual score with contributions from Dutch cellist and Herzog regular Ernst Reijseger.

 

Posted in Film, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on FILM REVIEW: Werner Herzog’s ‘Rescue Dawn’

Norman Mailer’s writing skill on display in ‘The Fight’

Ali v Foreman x650

By Ray Bennett

The books of Norman Mailer, who died today at 84, proved of such little interest to filmmakers that he directed adaptations of some of them himself including “Maidstone” (1970) and “Tough Guys Don’t Dance” (1987).

Lawrence Schiller made an Emmy-winning NBC miniseries of “The Executioner’s Song” starring Tommy Lee Jones as death row convict Gary Gilmore in 1982. The only other feature of note was Raoul Walsh’s 1958 version of Mailer’s World War II novel “The Naked and the Dead” starring Aldo Ray and Cliff Robertson.Norman Mailer x325

For my money, Mailer’s best writing was his journalism as in “The Executioner’s Song” but especially in his superb boxing yarn “The Fight,” which described the 1974 encounter between Muhammad Ali and George Foreman in Zaire known as the Rumble in the Jungle. Here’s an excerpt:

“Foreman’s arms flew out to the side like a man with a parachute jumping out of a plane, and in this doubled-over position he tried to wander out to the center of the ring. All the while his eyes were on Ali and he looked up with no anger as if Ali, indeed, was the man he knew best in the world and would see him on his dying day.

“Vertigo took George Foreman and revolved him. Still bowing from the waist in this uncomprehending position, eyes on Muhammad Ali all the way, he started to tumble and topple and fall even as he did not wish to go down. . . . He went over like a six-foot sixty-year-old butler who has just heard tragic news. . . .”

Here’s where to find it

Posted in Books, Comment, Film | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Norman Mailer’s writing skill on display in ‘The Fight’

Oscar won’t visit ‘Band’ but audiences certainly will

Autosave-File vom d-lab2/3 der AgfaPhoto GmbH

The delightful film “The Band’s Visit” (Bikur Ha-Tizmoret), starring Ronit Elkebetz and Sasson Gabai (pictured), which was a hit at the Festival de Cannes, opens at the Curzon Mayfair on Friday and in the United States on Dec. 7.

The picture was disqualified from contention as foreign language film at the Academy Awards following a ruling that more than 50% of the dialogue is in English and BAFTA’s rules for the category are the same: “All feature-length films with predominantly non-English dialogue are eligible.”

“The Band’s Visit” is about a ceremonial police band from Egypt on a trip to Israel for the opening of an Arab Cultural Centre. The troupe’s members arrive in the wrong town and their interaction with the locals means they must communicate in stumbling English.

The Oscars Foreign-Language Film Selection Committee Chairman, producer Mark Johnson told the Los Angeles Times: “You have to remember, it’s called best foreign-language film, not best foreign film. I’m heartbroken, because I loved the movie. But there wasn’t a single person on our committee that disagreed with the decision. If we accepted this film just because we liked it so much, the rules wouldn’t mean anything at all.”

It was my favorite at the Festival de Cannes this year and it’s a crying shame that it won’t be up for an Oscar and maybe a BAFTA, but great reviews and enthusiastic word of mouth will ensure it finds a wide audience.

“The Band’s Visit” is sophisticated filmmaking, wise about race with a great sense of humour so that the poignancy of its themes never get in the way of the entertaining story.

Posted in Festival de Cannes, Film, News | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Oscar won’t visit ‘Band’ but audiences certainly will

Of Canterbury, choristers and cowboys

By Ray Bennett

Roy Rogers cost me both a singing career and belief in the church. I am reminded of this because the BBC Young Chorister of the Year competition final airs on Radio 2 this evening at 8 o’clock and I once sang in a choir at Canterbury Cathedral.

The competition actually took place last weekend so the results have been announced. Far be it from me to ruin the suspense for those who tune in without knowing the outcome but listen for the perfect voice of a young man named Joel Whitewood. I am related to Joel, 12, through marriage, but that’s not why I mention it. The boy can sing.

He is one of 18 choristers who sing every day in Canterbury Cathedral where he is a side leader in the choir. Like the others, he is a student at Canterbury’s St. Edmund’s School. Dr. David Flood, the cathedral’s organist and master of choristers, is holding voice trials in Canterbury on Nov. 10 seeking five candidates for scholarships.

When I was a kid and thought I believed in a god, I was a soprano in the Ashford Parish Church choir in Kent. I was never in Joel’s league, but not terrible. It didn’t hurt that kids who sang in the choir were paid a handy amount of pocket money. I didn’t care for the incense burning at Sunday morning mass but I loved going out carol singing at Christmas and the mince pies and custard afterwards.

My choral life ended abruptly. Ours was among several choirs chosen to sing in a celebration of massed voices in Canterbury Cathedral under the direction, as I recall, of Sir Malcolm Sargent. It involved a full day’s rehearsal on a Saturday with the concert the next day. It was a huge honour.

The following year, we were invited again. In those days, all I wanted to do was play football and go to Hollywood to meet Roy Rogers (who was born, incidentally, on Nov. 5). The King of the Cowboys’ wretched television show never made it to England so he remained a hero. He’d long stopped making movies by then and they were rarely on TV and seldom came to Ashford.

But then came news of a matinee screening of “Pals of the Golden West” or something like that. Trouble was, it was on the day of rehearsal at Canterbury Cathedral. I went to the movie. I was promptly dismissed from the choir in ignominy. It was my first crisis of conscience. Roy Rogers versus Jesus Christ; Hollywood versus the Church. No contest. Oh, and I did go to Hollywood and I did meet Roy Rogers.

Read more about Canterbury Cathedral choristers.

Posted in Music, Notes | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

TV REVIEW: ‘A Room With a View’ by Andrew Davies

A Room with a View

By Ray Bennett

LONDON – The best thing about the new television adaptation of E.M. Forster’s novel “A Room with a View” is the music by Gabriel Yared. It’s not clear why the Beirut-born, Paris-based composer chose to do a TV film but viewers reap the reward.

Yared (pictured below) is on the A-list of film composers, having won the Academy Award, Golden Globe, BAFTA and Grammy for Anthony Minghella’s best picture Oscar winner “The English Patient” in 1997.

gabriel-yared-x325His great Oscar-nominated score for “Cold Mountain” won him another BAFTA (with T-Bone Burnett) and best original soundtrack and composer of the year honours at the World Soundtrack Awards in 2004. Other scores range from Robert Altman’s “Vincent & Theo” (1990) to Minghella’s “The Talented Mr. Ripley” (1999) and “Breaking and Entering” (2006), and Mikael Håfström’s 2007 thriller “1408.”

A concert performer who also gives his time to master class sessions at many events including the Flanders International Film Festival, Yared is a warm and approachable individual whose film music ranks with the best.

British writer Andrew Davies, who usually can be relied upon to bring a fresh, new approach to familiar material (“Vanity Fair,” “Dr. Zhivago,” “Bleak House”) is strangely off form in the new version of E.M. Forster’s “A Room With a View.

Elaine Cassidy and Rafe Spall (pictured) star with Laurence Fox, Sophie Thompson and Timothy Spall. It airs at 9 p.m. Sunday on ITV1 and is destined for PBS but it pales in comparison to the highly regarded Merchant-Ivory film from 1985 even though Davies has added bookends that place the love affair of Lucy Honeychurch in historical perspective.

Mischievously, Film4 will show James Ivory’s splendid film Sunday at 4:35 p.m. Helena Bonham Carter, Maggie Smith, Daniel Day-Lewis, Judi Dench, Julian Sands and Denholm Elliott are all terrific, and Richard Robbins’s music also is fine.

Robbins, who hails from Massachusetts, scored Merchant and Ivory films from “The Europeans” in 1979 through classics such as “Heat and Dust” (1983), “Howards End” (1992), and “The Remains of the Day” (1993) to “City of Your Final Destination,” which is due for release in 2008.

Here’s more on Gabriel Yared

Posted in Music, Reviews, Television | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on TV REVIEW: ‘A Room With a View’ by Andrew Davies

Malcolm McDowell’s Lindsay Anderson film at bfi

Paramount Pictures' "Aeon Flux" Los Angeles Premiere - ArrivalsBy Ray Bennett

Mike Kaplan’s film of Malcolm McDowell’s splendid one-man show “Never Apologize: A Personal Visit with Lindsay Anderson” opens at bfi Southbank today and will run through Nov. 18.

McDowell will be at bfi on Saturday Nov. 10 and Screen on the Hill Sunday Nov. 11 to talk about the late director with whom he made the classics “If …” and “O Lucky Man.”

See my review

Posted in Film, Notes | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on Malcolm McDowell’s Lindsay Anderson film at bfi

THEATRE REVIEW: Candida Cave’s ‘Lotte’s Journey’

Lottes-Journey

By Ray Bennett

LONDON — Charlotte Salomon was a young German Jewish woman who perished at Auschwitz in 1943 but who left hundreds of paintings that describe a short life lived in the shadow of the Nazi terror.

Candida Cave’s riveting new play, “Lotte’s Journey,” in its world premiere at London’s New End Theatre, portrays the sparking of her talent and the harrowing passage towards death in the Holocaust.

Set in a crowded cattle car ostensibly on its way from the French Riviera to a Jewish “settlement” in Poland, the play flashes back to Charlotte’s childhood in Berlin and adolescence with her grandparents on the Cote d’Azur.

Salomon made hundreds of gouaches – notebook-sized paintings with heavier pigmentation than water colours – to which she added descriptive words and musical clues to provide a narrative. She called her collection “Life? or Theater?” It was discovered in Amsterdam in the 1970s by history professor Mary Lowenthal Felstiner, whose subsequent book made the works famous. A 1981 film title “Charlotte” by Dutch director Frans Weisz, starred Birgit Doll as the title character and Derek Jacobi as her lover.

In the new play, Cave traces the development of Charlotte’s striving for creative freedom as an escape from the perilous times. Selina Chilton (pictured) is outstanding as the young painter, capturing her youthful innocence as well as the growing steel that sees her through to adulthood as an exceptional artist.

The rest of the cast, in multiple roles, do well too. James Pearse and Elizabeth Elvin makemuch of quite different characters; Dominic Power (pictured) is strong as a journalist and Charlotte’s lover; and Ben Elliot is downright scary as a pitiless Nazi guard.

On the small New End Theatre stage, efficiently cleverly by designer Lotte Collette with the cramped cattle car on the left and an open space for flashbacks on the right, the story plays out to increasing horror. David W. Kidd’s shrewd lighting design helps enormously to establish credibility.

As the story unfolds, the setting moves back and forth to Berlin with Charlotte as a child as the Nazi menace grows. Scenes depict her doctor father suffering from the new regime, her deeply troubled mother struggling for mental balance, and a new stepmother, an opera star, who encourages the girl’s artistic endeavors.

Charlotte falls in love with her stepmother’s vocal coach, Amadeus Daberlohn, but they are wrenched apart as she is returned to the south of France. There, the truth of her mother’s death is revealed, not from influenza but suicide. Her demanding grandfather relates the entire grisly family history in which every woman has died by her own hand.

That frightening legacy is the impulse that drives Charlotte as she begins to paint, evidently choosing life over death, although as the cattle car continues on its inexorable track, the play raises even more haunting questions.

Venue: New End Theatre, runs through Nov. 25; Cast: Selina Chilton; Ben Elliot; James Pearse; Elizabeth Elvin; Valerie Colgan; Max Digby; Dominic Power; Playwright: Candida Cave; Director: Ninon Jerome; Designer: Lotte Collett; Lighting designer: David W. Kidd; Sound designer: Paul Gavin; Music: Jeremy Haneman; Presented by New End Theatre and Pleasure for Pleasure in association with Beth Shalom Holocaust Centre.

Posted in Reviews, Theatre | Comments Off on THEATRE REVIEW: Candida Cave’s ‘Lotte’s Journey’

THEATRE REVIEW: Michael Ball in ‘Hairspray’

hairspray2

By Ray Bennett

“Hairspray” is still running in New York, and there has been a movie version starring John Travolta, but the 2003 Tony winner for best musical has finally made it to London’s West End in all its frenetic, infectious glory.

Staged by the same crew responsible for its Broadway run, the show features an all-British cast starring veteran leading man Michael Ball as Edna Turnblad and actor-director Mel Smith as her husband, Wilbur. Newcomer Leanne Jones rocks the house as Tracy, the rotund and redoubtable 1962 dancing queen who wants to win a spot on Baltimore’s top TV pop show.

The slick production has rounded the hard edges of John Waters’ original 1988 movie, but Mark O’Donnell’s book and song lyrics by Scott Witman and Marc Shaiman still carry plenty of punch. Tracy not only makes the case for the substantially circumferenced but also for integration, making the show a no-brainer where sentiment is concerned.

Shaiman’s rollicking musical numbers are the kind that makes sitting down impossible, and the high-adrenaline cast takes Jerry Mitchell’s lively choreography to the limit. Director Jack O’Brien maintains a good pace, though the first act, with its very simple plot, seems to take a while.

Not so for Act 2, however, which contains a fine showpiece for Ball and Smith titled “Timeless to Me.” Ball plays Edna broadly but with respect, and his fine voice doesn’t suffer at all from his being in drag. Smith (director of such films as “The Tall Guy” and “Bean: The Movie” and star of the long-running TV comedy series “Smith & Jones”) does Wilbur as Jimmy Durante, and no worse for that.

As Motormouth Maybelle, Johnnie Fiori delivers the soulful number “I Know Where I’ve Been” with such emotional power and clarity that she almost stops the show. But the fast-moving “Hairspray” and “You Can’t Stop the Beat” follow quickly to end the show at a furious tempo.

Tracie Bennett has a fine time as the racist former beauty queen Velma Von Tussle, Elinor Collett goes from ugly duckling to swan as Penny Pingleton and Ben James-Ellis makes the most of his Elvis impression as Link Larkin, and the entire cast give it all they’ve got.

Colorful, breezy and impossible to resist, “Hairspray” should provide London’s Shaftesbury Theatre, which is known for a long list of flops, a hit at last.

HAIRSPRAY

Venue: Shaftesbury Theatre, runs through March 15; Cast: Michael Ball; Mel Smith; Leanne Jones; Ben James-Ellis; Tracie Bennett; Natalie Best; Elinor Collett; Johnnie Fiori; Adrian Hansel; Paul Manuel; Wendy Somerville; Rachael Wooding; Book: Mark O’Donnell; Music: Marc Shaiman; Lyrics: Scott Witman, Marc Shaiman; Based on the New Line film written and directed by: John Waters; Director: Jack O’Brien; Choreographer: Jerry Mitchell; Set designer: David Rockwell; Costume designer: William Ivey Long; Lighting designer: Kenneth Posner; Sound designer: Steve C. Kennedy; Presented by Stage Entertainment U.K., Margo Lion, New Line, the Baruch-Vietel-Routh-Frankel Group, Elizabeth Williams, James D. Stern/Douglas L. Meyer, Cynthia Stroum.

This review appeared in The Hollywood Reporter.

Posted in Music, Reviews, Theatre | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on THEATRE REVIEW: Michael Ball in ‘Hairspray’

MUSIC REVIEW: Patrick Doyle: Music From the Movies

By Ray Bennett

“Wherever there is Pat, there is laughter, and his laugh can be heard across several counties,” said Imelda Staunton on Sunday at the Royal Albert Hall concert of film music by the great Scottish composer Patrick Doyle.

The BAFTA-winning actress (“Vera Drake”) was one of several performers and filmmakers there to celebrate Doyle’s Music From the Movies and raise money for leukemia research.

rtuk_feature_patrick_doyle_01They all spoke as much about his spirit as his music. Robbie Coltrane said: “Pat Doyle is probably the funniest man I’ve ever met in my life.” Director Mike Newell (“Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire”) called him a “phenomenal little wizard.”

Judi Dench said that his score for Kenneth Branagh’s “Henry V” spoke to “all those who fear the loss of hope.”

Doyle thanked his family and friends for seeing him through his own illness: “I have been blessed by inheriting the gift for music from my father and mother. I am the luckiest man alive.”

Here’s how my review of the concert Patrick Doyle: Music from the Movies begins in The Hollywood Reporter:

LONDON — Scottish film composer Patrick Doyle’s charity fundraiser had more than average resonance as the man who scored most of Kenneth Branagh’s films and such others as “Sense and Sensibility,” “Indochine,” and “Carlito’s Way” has successfully battled leukemia.

The concert was directed by Branagh and featured many of the actors and filmmakers associated with films featuring Doyle’s music including Emma Thompson, Alan Rickman, Robbie Coltrane, Richard E. Grant, Judi Dench, Mike Newell and Regis Wargnier.

Belgium’s Dirk Brosse led the London Symphony Orchestra and Chorus in almost three hours of sumptuous themes that play as well in the concert hall as they do in the motion pictures.

The first score Doyle wrote after his treatment was for Regis Wargnier’s “East/West”, a tale of sacrifice and loss in Stalin’s Soviet Union. Baritone Anatolij Fokanov sang Doyle’s evocative “The Land” from that score, raising the hair on the back of everyone’s neck.

The composer’s daughter Abigail Doyle performed “The Way It’s Meant to Be” from Robert Altman’s “Gosford Park” with great flair, and Beth Nielsen Chapman contributed the lovely “I Find Your Love”, which she co-wrote with Doyle for “Calendar Girls” though it didn’t make the finished film.

Thompson led “Sigh No More, Ladies” from “Much Ado About Nothing” playfully while pianist John Alley did justice to “My Father’s Favorite” and soprano Janis Kelly did likewise on “Weep No More, My Sad Fountains”, both from “Sense and Sensibility”. Soloist Carmine Lauri’s performance in the world premiere of the “Rosalind Violin Concerto”, inspired by “As You Like It”, resonated with passion.

Highlights of the evening were dramatic presentations by Derek Jacobi doing the “My thoughts be bloody” soliloquy from “Hamlet” and Branagh declaiming the “St. Crispin’s Day” speech from “Henry V”.

All of the guests were old pals of Doyle and their stories from the past 30 years added greatly to the entertainment. Not all of the stories were about Doyle, however. Rickman told of a note he received from Taiwanese director Ang Lee while filming “Sense and Sensibility”. His note read: “Be more subtle. Do more.” Patrick Doyle’s music is both subtle and marvellously rousing. There’s no doubt he will do more.

Posted in Film, Music, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on MUSIC REVIEW: Patrick Doyle: Music From the Movies